SharpJuice

Week 10

Win probability: model vs. Kalshi

Each game's model line converted to a win probability, next to the price on Kalshi's prediction market. Sorted by the biggest disagreement.

GameKalshi favoriteKalshiModelMarket spreadModel rates higher
Texas A&M at South Carolina South Carolina 71% 61% 67% Texas A&M +10 pts
Duke at NC State Duke 69% 59% 64% NC State +10 pts
Vanderbilt at Mississippi State Mississippi State 56% 65% 56% Mississippi State +9 pts
Oklahoma at Florida Florida 69% 60% 65% Oklahoma +9 pts
Texas State at Oregon State Oregon State 70% 61% 67% Texas State +9 pts
Marshall at Georgia Southern Georgia Southern 77% 68% 73% Marshall +8 pts
South Florida at East Carolina East Carolina 52% 44% 53% South Florida +8 pts
New Mexico at Nevada New Mexico 80% 72% 73% Nevada +8 pts
Oklahoma State at Kansas State Oklahoma State 62% 54% 58% Kansas State +8 pts
TCU at Arizona Arizona 75% 67% 71% TCU +8 pts
Cincinnati at Houston Houston 79% 72% 73% Cincinnati +8 pts
Fresno State at Utah State Fresno State 55% 62% 55% Fresno State +8 pts
Arkansas at Auburn Auburn 78% 71% 73% Arkansas +7 pts
Rice at North Texas North Texas 89% 83% 82% Rice +6 pts
Rutgers at Wisconsin Wisconsin 87% 81% 83% Rutgers +6 pts
Iowa at Northwestern Northwestern 53% 47% 55% Iowa +6 pts
Missouri State at FIU FIU 64% 58% 59% Missouri State +6 pts
Alabama at LSU LSU 64% 59% 63% Alabama +6 pts
UTSA at Florida Atlantic UTSA 71% 65% 67% Florida Atlantic +6 pts
South Alabama at Louisiana Louisiana 76% 70% 72% South Alabama +6 pts
Nebraska at Illinois Nebraska 65% 60% 62% Illinois +6 pts
Toledo at Sacramento State Toledo 94% 88% 91% Sacramento State +5 pts
Clemson at Syracuse Clemson 53% 58% 53% Clemson +5 pts
Texas at Missouri Texas 57% 62% 56% Texas +5 pts
Hawai’i at UTEP Hawai’i 76% 71% 72% UTEP +5 pts
Delaware at Kennesaw State Delaware 55% 50% 56% Kennesaw State +5 pts
Florida State at Boston College Florida State 70% 65% 65% Boston College +5 pts
Tulsa at Tulane Tulsa 51% 46% 53% Tulane +5 pts
Old Dominion at Coastal Carolina Coastal Carolina 71% 66% 67% Old Dominion +4 pts
Temple at Navy Navy 72% 68% 67% Temple +4 pts
Sam Houston at Jacksonville State Jacksonville State 87% 82% 83% Sam Houston +4 pts
Liberty at New Mexico State Liberty 88% 83% 83% New Mexico State +4 pts
UL Monroe at Arkansas State Arkansas State 85% 81% 80% UL Monroe +4 pts
Maryland at Purdue Purdue 68% 65% 65% Maryland +4 pts
Miami at Notre Dame Notre Dame 64% 60% 61% Miami +4 pts
Western Kentucky at Middle Tennessee Western Kentucky 50% 54% 50% Western Kentucky +4 pts
Louisville at Georgia Tech Louisville 83% 79% 80% Georgia Tech +4 pts
Central Michigan vs Eastern Michigan Eastern Michigan 53% 49% 53% Central Michigan +4 pts
Iowa State at Baylor Baylor 76% 72% 72% Iowa State +3 pts
West Virginia at Texas Tech Texas Tech 86% 82% 83% West Virginia +3 pts
Boise State at Colorado State Boise State 88% 85% 84% Colorado State +3 pts
Air Force at Army Army 61% 58% 58% Air Force +3 pts
Colorado at Arizona State Arizona State 61% 64% 58% Arizona State +3 pts
Penn State at Washington Washington 53% 51% 53% Penn State +3 pts
James Madison at Southern Miss James Madison 86% 83% 81% Southern Miss +3 pts
North Carolina at UConn North Carolina 72% 69% 67% UConn +3 pts
Georgia at Ole Miss Georgia 59% 61% 58% Georgia +1 pts
Wyoming at UNLV UNLV 70% 69% 67% Wyoming +1 pts
BYU at Utah Utah 64% 66% 64% Utah +1 pts
UCLA at Minnesota UCLA 66% 65% 64% Minnesota +1 pts
Charlotte at UAB UAB 79% 78% 73% Charlotte +1 pts
Kentucky at Tennessee Tennessee 66% 65% 65% Kentucky +1 pts
Northern Illinois at San Jose State San Jose State 78% 77% 73% Northern Illinois +1 pts
Louisiana Tech at Troy Louisiana Tech 65% 64% 63% Troy +1 pts
Ball State at UMass UMass 60% 61% 58% UMass +1 pts
Ohio at Akron Ohio 80% 80% 77% Akron +1 pts
Georgia State at Appalachian State Appalachian State 62% 62% 58% Appalachian State +0 pts
Buffalo at Miami (OH) Miami (OH) 69% 69% 65% Buffalo +0 pts
Virginia Tech at SMU SMU 67% 67% 65% SMU +0 pts
Oregon at Ohio State Ohio State 72% 71% 68% Oregon +0 pts
UCF at Kansas Kansas 58% 58% 57% UCF +0 pts

All probabilities are shown for Kalshi's favorite. Model and market-spread probabilities use the Winston formula, P = 0.5 + 0.5 × (1 − e−0.0454·|S|1.12), where S is the projected margin. The formula is more conservative than prediction markets on big favorites, so compare the "Market spread" column with Kalshi to see how much of a gap is the formula itself rather than the model. Kalshi = midpoint of the bid and ask, normalized across both teams; "thin" marks a wide bid/ask spread.